Welcome!

SDN Journal Authors: Barbara Porter, Yeshim Deniz, Sandi Mappic, Lori MacVittie, Elizabeth White

Related Topics: SDN Journal, Java, SOA & WOA, Linux, Virtualization

SDN Journal: Blog Feed Post

SDN's Eventually Consistent Network Problem

Clustering controllers to address scalability concerns introduces a well-understood problem: consistency

One of the benefits of SDN is centralized control. That is, there is a single repository containing the known current state of the entire network. It is this centralization that enables intelligent application of new policies to govern and control the network - from new routes to user experience services like QoS. Because there is a single entity which has visibility into the state of the network as a whole, it can examine the topology at any given point and make determinations as to where this packet and that should be routed, how it is prioritized and even whether or not it is allowed to traverse the network.

It's a pretty powerful concept for networks, which traditionally distribute network state as individual configuration files across the data path.

network-state-traditional

Most of the focus of SDN is on the replacement of manual and scripted configuration methods with an API-driven mechanism. Whether that's OpenFlow or OpFlex or some other protocol is not really important as the benefit of operationalization is to provide a consistent interface from the perspective of the operator, not the device.

network-state-sdn

This is a real benefit; operationalization across operations and dev has proven to produce tangible benefits in the form of improved time to market and a reduction in errors. By centralizing network state in a controller, this model provides a comprehensive view of the network at any given moment. Because the controller is not just a repository but an active participant in the flow of data across the network, this visibility enables the controller to understand how to (ostensibly) non-disruptively change routes or apply new policies in real-time.

The benefit itself is not in question. What is in question is what happens when the controller of this new software-defined architecture becomes overwhelmed, and how to preserve that benefit when the centralized model must decentralize in order to scale.

The Eventually Consistent Problem Comes to the Network

Eventual consistency is nothing new. It has always been an issue when scaling applications, particularly those that rely on shared data. Consider Amazon, if you will. If you and I are both shopping for the same thing, and I order before you, it may take seconds or more before the database is updated. If you were in the middle of ordering at the same time, you and I may be contending for the same item. Because my order takes a moment or two to propagate through the system, your view of the database (the availability of the item) is inconsistent with mine.

It is assumed that eventually our views will be consistent, and that this age old unsolved problem of distributed computing simply must be accepted as unsolvable for now,  Thus systems are designed with this principle in mind. Which means we end up back with Brewer's CAP Theorem staring us in the face and reminding us we can't be perfectly consistent in a distributed system, so we must deal with systems in such a way as to achieve eventually consistency.

At issue is the ability of a software controller to scale. The controller is, by design and necessity, part of the data path. That is both a blessing and a curse. It is from this fact that the real-time adaption of network behavior can be achieved, but it is also this fact which forces issues of scale and introduces the need for a distributed system from which the problem of eventual consistency derives. That's because more than one system will be the "master" repository for a given portion of network state. Even if one controller is designated as master of the network universe and thus maintains the "official" state of the network, there are those moments when the secondary (or tertiary) controller has modified the "official" state and introduces inconsistency. In the moments between when the two network states merge, there is the possibility that the first (master) controller will also try to make a decision based on information that relies on network state that is no longer valid. If Controller B, for example, removes a port from a VLAN, and before that state can propagate to the master, a packet arrives in the fabric, destined for that port, Controller A will have no way to know that it is no longer participating in the VLAN and will, as expected, tell the switch to route to that port.

The issue will be shortly resolved, assuming timely synchronization of network state across the cluster, but in the meantime performance (or availability) may be negatively impacted.

clustered-sdn

The problem with eventual consistency in the network is one of magnitude. Eventually consistent views of books in stock at Amazon has a very different impact than an eventually consistent view of the network underpinning today's applications and ultimately the business. We're not talking about losing out on a book, we're talking about potentially disrupting hundreds or thousands of applications that translates into hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars. Ponemon's 2013 Cost of Data Center Outages proves this case out: "The average reported outage incident length was 86 minutes, resulting in average cost per incident of about $690,200."

Eventual consistency of the network may turn out to be quite costly.

Common Themes: Reliability and Control

This is not a new problem. This issue of stateful failover as applied to scalability of both infrastructure and applications is one that application delivery has been dealing with, well, for over a decade now. The issue when dealing with distributed state is always one of replication and synchronization between those devices providing for reliability. That doesn't change just because we move from one form factor to another, or from on-premise to cloud. The issue remains: how do we maintain an authoritative view of the state of an <application or network> while still enabling the scale necessary to meet demand?

While we (as in the industry "we") recognize that true stateful reliability - and thus perfect consistency - is currently unachievable due to the constraints of distributed system design, we also recognize that we can get pretty darn close. From an application perspective, the intelligence embedded in a service fabric is more than able to deal with the problem with minimal introduction of latency. That is, there will be a slight pause and some disruption when failure or disruption occurs in the network but if the service fabric is smart enough, the disruption is experienced by the end user as no more than a slight hiccup - likely unnoticeable.

But the further down the stack you go, toward core network function, the more disruptive such a hiccup is going to be.

That's one of the reasons a "centralized control, decentralized execution" architecture makes more sense from a network perspective. Such a model maintains authoritative control over the state of the network, but empowers individual components in the various fabrics (stateless L2-4 and stateful L4-7) that make up "the network" to maintain its own prescriptive configuration and take action when necessary based on the abstracted policies of the network as a whole.

Everyone likes to posit an answer to what will be the "killer app" for SDN. But before we can worry about that, we might want to consider what may be the "showstopper" obstacles for SDN. Eventual consistency when scaling controllers is one of those issues.

Because without a reliable and consistent network world, there is no application world. Or at least not one that users will be excited to rely on.

Read the original blog entry...

More Stories By Lori MacVittie

Lori MacVittie is responsible for education and evangelism of application services available across F5’s entire product suite. Her role includes authorship of technical materials and participation in a number of community-based forums and industry standards organizations, among other efforts. MacVittie has extensive programming experience as an application architect, as well as network and systems development and administration expertise. Prior to joining F5, MacVittie was an award-winning Senior Technology Editor at Network Computing Magazine, where she conducted product research and evaluation focused on integration with application and network architectures, and authored articles on a variety of topics aimed at IT professionals. Her most recent area of focus included SOA-related products and architectures. She holds a B.S. in Information and Computing Science from the University of Wisconsin at Green Bay, and an M.S. in Computer Science from Nova Southeastern University.

Cloud Expo Breaking News
As more applications and services move "to the cloud" (public or on-premise) cloud environments are increasingly adopting and building out traditional enterprise features. This in turn is enabling and encouraging cloud adoption from enterprise users. In many ways the definition is blurring as features like continuous operation, geo-distribution or on-demand capacity become the norm. NuoDB is involved in both building enterprise software and using enterprise cloud capabilities. In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Seth Proctor, CTO at NuoDB, Inc., will discuss the experiences from building, deploying and using enterprise services and suggest some ways to approach moving enterprise applications into a cloud model.
Until recently, many organizations required specialized departments to perform mapping and geospatial analysis, and they used Esri on-premise solutions for that work. In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Dave Peters, author of the Esri Press book Building a GIS, System Architecture Design Strategies for Managers, will discuss how Esri has successfully included the cloud as a fully integrated SaaS expansion of the ArcGIS mapping platform. Organizations that have incorporated Esri cloud-based applications and content within their business models are reaping huge benefits by directly leveraging cloud-based mapping and analysis capabilities within their existing enterprise investments. The ArcGIS mapping platform includes cloud-based content management and information resources to more widely, efficiently, and affordably deliver real-time actionable information and analysis capabilities to your organization.
In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Mark Hinkle, Senior Director, Open Source Solutions at Citrix Systems Inc., will provide overview of the open source software that can be used to deploy and manage a cloud computing environment. He will include information on storage, networking(e.g., OpenDaylight) and compute virtualization (Xen, KVM, LXC) and the orchestration(Apache CloudStack, OpenStack) of the three to build their own cloud services. Speaker Bio: Mark Hinkle is the Senior Director, Open Source Solutions, at Citrix Systems Inc. He joined Citrix as a result of their July 2011 acquisition of Cloud.com where he was their Vice President of Community. He is currently responsible for Citrix open source efforts around the open source cloud computing platform, Apache CloudStack and the Xen Hypervisor. Previously he was the VP of Community at Zenoss Inc., a producer of the open source application, server, and network management software, where he grew the Zenoss Core project to over 10...
Almost everyone sees the potential of Internet of Things but how can businesses truly unlock that potential. The key will be in the ability to discover business insight in the midst of an ocean of Big Data generated from billions of embedded devices via Systems of Discover. Businesses will also need to ensure that they can sustain that insight by leveraging the cloud for global reach, scale and elasticity. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Mac Devine, Distinguished Engineer at IBM, will discuss bringing these three elements together via Systems of Discover.
Cloud and Big Data present unique dilemmas: embracing the benefits of these new technologies while maintaining the security of your organization’s assets. When an outside party owns, controls and manages your infrastructure and computational resources, how can you be assured that sensitive data remains private and secure? How do you best protect data in mixed use cloud and big data infrastructure sets? Can you still satisfy the full range of reporting, compliance and regulatory requirements? In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Derek Tumulak, Vice President of Product Management at Vormetric, will discuss how to address data security in cloud and Big Data environments so that your organization isn’t next week’s data breach headline.
The cloud is everywhere and growing, and with it SaaS has become an accepted means for software delivery. SaaS is more than just a technology, it is a thriving business model estimated to be worth around $53 billion dollars by 2015, according to IDC. The question is – how do you build and scale a profitable SaaS business model? In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Jason Cumberland, Vice President, SaaS Solutions at Dimension Data, will give the audience an understanding of common mistakes businesses make when transitioning to SaaS; how to avoid them; and how to build a profitable and scalable SaaS business.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Gridstore™, the leader in software-defined storage (SDS) purpose-built for Windows Servers and Hyper-V, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 15th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on November 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Gridstore™ is the leader in software-defined storage purpose built for virtualization that is designed to accelerate applications in virtualized environments. Using its patented Server-Side Virtual Controller™ Technology (SVCT) to eliminate the I/O blender effect and accelerate applications Gridstore delivers vmOptimized™ Storage that self-optimizes to each application or VM across both virtual and physical environments. Leveraging a grid architecture, Gridstore delivers the first end-to-end storage QoS to ensure the most important App or VM performance is never compromised. The storage grid, that uses Gridstore’s performance optimized nodes or capacity optimized nodes, starts with as few a...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Solgenia, the global market leader in Cloud Collaboration and Cloud Infrastructure software solutions, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 15th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on November 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Solgenia is the global market leader in Cloud Collaboration and Cloud Infrastructure software solutions. Designed to “Bridge the Gap” between personal and professional social, mobile and cloud user experiences, our solutions help large and medium-sized organizations dramatically improve productivity, reduce collaboration costs, and increase the overall enterprise value by bringing collaboration and infrastructure solutions to the cloud.
Cloud computing started a technology revolution; now DevOps is driving that revolution forward. By enabling new approaches to service delivery, cloud and DevOps together are delivering even greater speed, agility, and efficiency. No wonder leading innovators are adopting DevOps and cloud together! In his session at DevOps Summit, Andi Mann, Vice President of Strategic Solutions at CA Technologies, will explore the synergies in these two approaches, with practical tips, techniques, research data, war stories, case studies, and recommendations.
Enterprises require the performance, agility and on-demand access of the public cloud, and the management, security and compatibility of the private cloud. The solution? In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Simone Brunozzi, VP and Chief Technologist(global role) for VMware, will explore how to unlock the power of the hybrid cloud and the steps to get there. He'll discuss the challenges that conventional approaches to both public and private cloud computing, and outline the tough decisions that must be made to accelerate the journey to the hybrid cloud. As part of the transition, an Infrastructure-as-a-Service model will enable enterprise IT to build services beyond their data center while owning what gets moved, when to move it, and for how long. IT can then move forward on what matters most to the organization that it supports – availability, agility and efficiency.
Every healthy ecosystem is diverse. This is especially true in cloud ecosystems, where portability and interoperability are more important than old enterprise models of proprietary ownership. In his session at 15th Cloud Expo, Mark Baker, Server Product Manager at Canonical/Ubuntu, will discuss how single vendors used to take the lead in creating and delivering technology, but in a cloud economy, where users want tools of their preference, when and where they need them, it makes no sense.
The 15th International Cloud Expo has just expanded its conference program, to bring together Cloud Computing, APM, APIs, Security, Big Data, Internet of Things, DevOps and WebRTC at one location. Cloud Expo is the single show where delegates and technology vendors can meet to experience and discuss the entire world of the cloud. With cloud computing driving a higher percentage of enterprise IT budgets every year, it becomes increasingly important to learn about the latest technology developments and solutions.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Bsquare Corporation, a leading enabler of smart connected systems, has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's Internet of @ThingsExpo, which will take place on November 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Bsquare is a global leader of embedded software solutions. We enable smart connected systems at the device level and beyond that millions use every day and provide actionable data solutions for the growing Internet of Things (IoT) market. We empower our world-class customers with our products, services and solutions to achieve innovation and success.
SYS-CON Events announced today that NuoDB, Inc., the leader in webscale distributed database technology, has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 15th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on November 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. NuoDB was launched in 2010 by industry-renowned database architect Jim Starkey and accomplished software CEO Barry Morris to deliver a webscale distributed database management system that is specifically designed for the cloud and the modern datacenter.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Cloudian, Inc., the leading provider of hybrid cloud storage solutions, has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 15th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on November 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Cloudian is a Foster City, Calif.-based software company specializing in cloud storage. Cloudian HyperStore® is an S3-compatible cloud object storage platform that enables service providers and enterprises to build reliable, affordable and scalable hybrid cloud storage solutions. Cloudian actively partners with leading cloud computing environments including Amazon Web Services, Citrix Cloud Platform, Apache CloudStack, OpenStack and the vast ecosystem of S3 compatible tools and applications. Cloudian's customers include Vodafone, Nextel, NTT, Nifty, and LunaCloud. The company has additional offices in China and Japan.