Welcome!

SDN Journal Authors: Pat Romanski, Elizabeth White, Gil Allouche, Lori MacVittie, Dana Gardner

Related Topics: Java, SOA & WOA, .NET, Red Hat, Cloud Expo, SDN Journal

Java: Blog Feed Post

NoSQL and Partition Tolerance

While NoSQL implementations are aware that nodes have left, they are not aware that said nodes have formed a separate partition

I came across an article discussing NoSQL and partition tolerance.

The NoSQL Partition Tolerance Myth (link)

I may not entirely agree with the author.

But what most NoSQL systems offer is a peculiar behavior that is not partition tolerant, but partition oblivious instead.

 

No argument here. While NoSQL implementations are aware that nodes have left, they are not aware that said nodes have formed a separate partition.

In this case, we would want failure detection and carry out those transfers where the accounts are both on the same side of the partition, while denying or deferring transfers that cross the chasm.

The author is assuming that the account is only on one side of the partition. If that is that is case, is doesn’t matter whether the NoSQL implementation is eventually consistent or not. If the account is on both sides of the partition, the solution the author provides still results in an inconsistent state.

In such cases, it is almost always better to build services that degrade gracefully under partitions.

Bingo! The author implies that all NoSQL implementations sacrifice consistency in the event of a partition. That is not true. There are AP implementations (available & partition tolerant), and there are CP implementations (consistent & partition tolerant). However, an AP implementation can function as a CP implementation depending on the configuration and the application. For example, if accounts do not have multiple owners and the application can not withdraw funds from or deposit funds to an account if it can not access the account.

This post is not perfect and it is a bit outdated, but I think its helpful nonetheless.

Visual Guide to NoSQL Systems (link)

If I were to build a bank based on Dynamo, the granddaddy of all first-generation NoSQL data stores, it would silently split into two halves, like a lobotomized patient.

I would not say that Amazon Dynamo is the grandparent of all NoSQL implementations. I would say that there are two parents: Amazon Dynamo and Google BigTable. Then there are the grandparents…

A Brief History of NoSQL (link)

In this scenario, the hypothetical backend for Banko Dynamo would not only not provide any indication of failure, but allow a customer to create as many new accounts as there are partitions, one in each.

Why is the author now using account creation instead of withdrawals and deposits, and what is the relevance of creating multiple accounts? If my debit card does not work, I do not create a new account. That, and I maintain two checking accounts and one savings account with the same bank.

Let’s go back to withdrawals and deposits. If the accounts do not have multiple owners, it does not matter whether the NoSQL implementation is eventually consistent or not. If the accounts do have multiple owners, it depends on the NoSQL implementation. If it is inspired by Google BigTable (e.g. Apache HBase) or both Google BigTable and Amazon Dynamo (e.g. Apache Cassandra), it does not matter. These NoSQL implementations are CP, or can be configured to be CP. If it inspired only by Amazon Dynamo and it is eventually consistent, it may or may not matter…

Let’s assume that account withdrawals / deposits are separate from the accounts themselves and that the account is both consistent and available during a partition. The account has multiple owners but it is more or less read only.

My account has a balance of $100 (calculated from the withdrawals and deposits). Now, there are two partitions: A and B. I purchase $50 of St. Bernardus Abt 12 at Binny’s via partition A. Partition A now has withdrawal #1. I have dinner at Baume & Brix for $75 via partition B. Partition B now has withdrawal #2. My account has a balance of $50 in partition A. It has a balance of $25 in partition B. My account should have a balance of minus $25.

Does it matter? My account may not have a balance of minus $25, but it will. When the partition is repaired, the application will be able to access all of the withdrawals and deposits on my account. I may be charged an overlimit fee.

What if the NoSQL implementation sacrificed availability? My payment at Binny’s did not go through. That’s not a problem. No St. Bernardus Abt 12 for me. My payment at Baume & Brix did not go through. That’s a problem. I can’t pay for dinner. Baume & Brix can’t accept my payment nor that of any other customer paying with a debit card from the same bank as me via partition B.

What if I made a deposit of $25 at an ATM via partition A? My account will have a balance of $0 after the partition is repaired. I will not be charged an overlimit fee.

There are other scenarios. Perhaps I’m charged an insufficient funds fee and Baume & Brix does not receive payment. Perhaps Baume & Brix later resubmits the payment and receives payment.

Do you really want to sell tickets from both halves of your system? By definition, there is no way you can guarantee uniqueness of those tickets. There will be customers holding identical tickets with identical seat numbers.

Maybe, maybe not. If there is only a single owner per ticket, then yes. However, there may be availability issues. For example, partition A has tickets 1-150 and partition B has tickets 151-200. If all the tickets in partition B have been purchased, visitors may be unable to purchase tickets despite the fact that there may be tickets available in partition A. If there are multiple owners per ticket, I would prefer a NoSQL implementation that is CP. In this case, I would prefer to sacrifice availability rather than consistency.

Here is a better example. What if I report my debit card stolen? Sacrificing availability is not appropriate. What if customer service is accessing my account via the partition with no availability? My debit card must be reported stolen or the thief can continue to make purchases with it. Sacrificing consistency is not appropriate. The thief can continue to make purchases with my debit card via the partition where my account has not been reported stolen. Perhaps account information should not be stored in a distributed system.

And if they did, the first-generation NoSQL stores usually take the ultimate punt by presenting all versions of the divergent objects to the application, and let the application resolve the mess.

No argument here.

But if your data is that soft and inconsequential, why not just use memcached? It’s wicked fast, far faster than Mongo.

Perhaps because MongoDB is a document store and as such provides features that are not provided by key / value stores.

A lot of NoSQL developers pretend that being partition oblivious is a difficult thing to implement. This is false. It’s easy to make a program oblivious to a particular event; namely, you write no code to handle that event.

No argument here.

The thing that greatly helps first generation NoSQL data stores, the thing that enables them to package partition obliviousness as if it were equivalent to partition tolerance, is that they provide a very weak service guarantee in the first place. These systems cannot guarantee that, on a good day, your GET will return the latest PUT.

Sure they can.

In fact, eventual consistency means that a GET can return any previous value, including the Does Not Exist response from the very initial state of the system.

No argument here. Of course, not all NoSQL implementations are eventually consistent.


With all this being said, a NoSQL implementation may or may not be appropriate. To be more specific, a NoSQL implementation that is eventually consistent and sacrifices consistency in the event of a partition may or may not be appropriate. The behaviour is determined by the NoSQL implementation, its configuration, and the application that reads and writes to it. Whether that behaviour is appropriate or not depends on the business requirements.

Read the original blog entry...

More Stories By Daniel Thompson

I curate the content on this page, but the credit goes to my talented colleagues for the posts that you see here. Much of what you read on this page is the work of friends at How to JBoss, and I encourage you to drop by the site at http://www.howtojboss.com for some of the best JBoss technical and non-technical content for developers, architects and technology executives on the Web.

@CloudExpo Stories
Some developers believe that monitoring is a function of the operations team. Some operations teams firmly believe that monitoring the systems they maintain is sufficient to run the business successfully. Most of them are wrong. The complexity of today's applications have gone far and beyond the capabilities of "traditional" system-level monitoring tools and approaches and requires much broader knowledge of business and applications as a whole. The goal of DevOps is to connect all aspects of app...
The 4th International DevOps Summit, co-located with16th International Cloud Expo – being held June 9-11, 2015, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY – announces that its Call for Papers is now open. Born out of proven success in agile development, cloud computing, and process automation, DevOps is a macro trend you cannot afford to miss. From showcase success stories from early adopters and web-scale businesses, DevOps is expanding to organizations of all sizes, including the world's large...
15th Cloud Expo, which took place Nov. 4-6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA, expanded the conference content of @ThingsExpo, Big Data Expo, and DevOps Summit to include two developer events. IBM held a Bluemix Developer Playground on November 5 and ElasticBox held a Hackathon on November 6. Both events took place on the expo floor. The Bluemix Developer Playground, for developers of all levels, highlighted the ease of use of Bluemix, its services and functionalit...
When an enterprise builds a hybrid IaaS cloud connecting its data center to one or more public clouds, security is often a major topic along with the other challenges involved. Security is closely intertwined with the networking choices made for the hybrid cloud. Traditional networking approaches for building a hybrid cloud try to kludge together the enterprise infrastructure with the public cloud. Consequently this approach requires risky, deep "surgery" including changes to firewalls, subnets...
Want to enable self-service provisioning of application environments in minutes that mirror production? Can you automatically provide rich data with code-level detail back to the developers when issues occur in production? In his session at DevOps Summit, David Tesar, Microsoft Technical Evangelist on Microsoft Azure and DevOps, will discuss how to accomplish this and more utilizing technologies such as Microsoft Azure, Visual Studio online, and Application Insights in this demo-heavy session.
DevOps is all about agility. However, you don't want to be on a high-speed bus to nowhere. The right DevOps approach controls velocity with a tight feedback loop that not only consists of operational data but also incorporates business context. With a business context in the decision making, the right business priorities are incorporated, which results in a higher value creation. In his session at DevOps Summit, Todd Rader, Solutions Architect at AppDynamics, discussed key monitoring techniques...
The Internet of Things will greatly expand the opportunities for data collection and new business models driven off of that data. In her session at @ThingsExpo, Esmeralda Swartz, CMO of MetraTech, discussed how for this to be effective you not only need to have infrastructure and operational models capable of utilizing this new phenomenon, but increasingly service providers will need to convince a skeptical public to participate. Get ready to show them the money!
SYS-CON Media announced that Centrify, a provider of unified identity management across cloud, mobile and data center environments that delivers single sign-on (SSO) for users and a simplified identity infrastructure for IT, has launched an ad campaign on Cloud Computing Journal. The ads focus on security: how an organization can successfully control privilege for all of the organization’s identities to mitigate identity-related risk without slowing down the business, and how Centrify provides ...
The Internet of Things will put IT to its ultimate test by creating infinite new opportunities to digitize products and services, generate and analyze new data to improve customer satisfaction, and discover new ways to gain a competitive advantage across nearly every industry. In order to help corporate business units to capitalize on the rapidly evolving IoT opportunities, IT must stand up to a new set of challenges. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Jeff Kaplan, Managing Director of THINKstrateg...
"We help companies that are using a lot of Software as a Service. We help companies manage and gain visibility into what people are using inside the company and decide to secure them or use standards to lock down or to embrace the adoption of SaaS inside the company," explained Scott Kriz, Co-founder and CEO of Bitium, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 15th Cloud Expo, held Nov 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
"SAP had made a big transition into the cloud as we believe it has significant value for our customers, drives innovation and is easy to consume. When you look at the SAP portfolio, SAP HANA is the underlying platform and it powers all of our platforms and all of our analytics," explained Thorsten Leiduck, VP ISVs & Digital Commerce at SAP, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 15th Cloud Expo, held Nov 4-6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
One of the biggest challenges when developing connected devices is identifying user value and delivering it through successful user experiences. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Mike Kuniavsky, Principal Scientist, Innovation Services at PARC, described an IoT-specific approach to user experience design that combines approaches from interaction design, industrial design and service design to create experiences that go beyond simple connected gadgets to create lasting, multi-device exp...
SAP is delivering break-through innovation combined with fantastic user experience powered by the market-leading in-memory technology, SAP HANA. In his General Session at 15th Cloud Expo, Thorsten Leiduck, VP ISVs & Digital Commerce, SAP, discussed how SAP and partners provide cloud and hybrid cloud solutions as well as real-time Big Data offerings that help companies of all sizes and industries run better. SAP launched an application challenge to award the most innovative SAP HANA and SAP HANA...
Enthusiasm for the Internet of Things has reached an all-time high. In 2013 alone, venture capitalists spent more than $1 billion dollars investing in the IoT space. With "smart" appliances and devices, IoT covers wearable smart devices, cloud services to hardware companies. Nest, a Google company, detects temperatures inside homes and automatically adjusts it by tracking its user's habit. These technologies are quickly developing and with it come challenges such as bridging infrastructure gaps,...
"Cloud consumption is something we envision at Solgenia. That is trying to let the cloud spread to the user as a consumption, as utility computing. We want to allow the people to just pay for what they use, not a subscription model," explained Ermanno Bonifazi, CEO & Founder of Solgenia, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at Cloud Expo, held Nov 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
The Domain Name Service (DNS) is one of the most important components in networking infrastructure, enabling users and services to access applications by translating URLs (names) into IP addresses (numbers). Because every icon and URL and all embedded content on a website requires a DNS lookup loading complex sites necessitates hundreds of DNS queries. In addition, as more internet-enabled ‘Things' get connected, people will rely on DNS to name and find their fridges, toasters and toilets. Acco...
"For the past 4 years we have been working mainly to export. For the last 3 or 4 years the main market was Russia. In the past year we have been working to expand our footprint in Europe and the United States," explained Andris Gailitis, CEO of DEAC, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at Cloud Expo, held Nov 4–6, 2014, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
Connected devices and the Internet of Things are getting significant momentum in 2014. In his session at Internet of @ThingsExpo, Jim Hunter, Chief Scientist & Technology Evangelist at Greenwave Systems, examined three key elements that together will drive mass adoption of the IoT before the end of 2015. The first element is the recent advent of robust open source protocols (like AllJoyn and WebRTC) that facilitate M2M communication. The second is broad availability of flexible, cost-effective ...
Scott Jenson leads a project called The Physical Web within the Chrome team at Google. Project members are working to take the scalability and openness of the web and use it to talk to the exponentially exploding range of smart devices. Nearly every company today working on the IoT comes up with the same basic solution: use my server and you'll be fine. But if we really believe there will be trillions of these devices, that just can't scale. We need a system that is open a scalable and by using ...
High-performing enterprise Software Quality Assurance (SQA) teams validate systems that are ready for use - getting most actively involved as components integrate and form complete systems. These teams catch and report on defects, making sure the customer gets the best software possible. SQA teams have leveraged automation and virtualization to execute more thorough testing in less time - bringing Dev and Ops together, ensuring production readiness. Does the emergence of DevOps mean the end of E...