Welcome!

SDN Journal Authors: Pat Romanski, Elizabeth White, Brad Anderson, Liz McMillan, Greg O'Connor

Related Topics: Cloud Expo, Java, SOA & WOA, Virtualization, Big Data Journal, SDN Journal

Cloud Expo: Blog Feed Post

All for the Want of a Global Load Balancer

Thoughts on the AWS / Netflix Christmas Eve Elastic Load Balancer Event

Christmas Eve and the AWS/Netflix outage to me aren't so much about whether or not the Cloud is viable or scary or dangerous. Rather, the event resonated with users across the United States because the Cloud delivers so much utility to each of us. And regardless of who was at fault -- Netflix or Amazon Web Services, the event made it clear that there's no going back and that the Cloud has quickly become a part of our culture and our everyday lives. This is significant because while the Internet itself is a technology consumers have grown to love, Cloud is a way of delivering service that makes a service like Netflix streaming possible, and at a measly $8 bucks a month. The Netflix business model of delivering outsize utility for a low price point makes the business of streaming video all the more difficult. HBO, Cinemax, and the networks for me are unusable. I sense something beyond just making money remains in play at Netflix. Somewhere in that organization seems to beat a heart that quickens for humanity.


While much is made of the sparsity of the Netflix streaming catalog, keep in mind that streaming is the disruptor's second act. The Wicked Witch, aka Blockbuster is dead, I think in part because each of us desired a little bit of payback for all the times we returned videos late and were charged outrageous fees. Rather than punish Netflix Streaming for innovating, and for challenging the iron grip of the legacy media houses, I praise Netflix and personally admire the generous open source contributions Netflix has made to the Cloud Community.

I once tweeted that the value of the code and tools Netflix has shared on GitHub may well be larger than the value of the streaming business as a whole. That may be true for about five minutes. We're at a tipping point in streaming video media similar to that of the music business just before the iPod. Yet each evolution carries forward a little bit of spin from the last disruption. In this iteration all the players know the iPod playbook and so they are trying very very hard to fight the gravity of disruption. Having lost Blockbuster and effective control over the distribution of their content, the old guard hold onto to their catalog stubbornly hoping Netflix will disappear. But we all know how this movie ends. I see a much larger Netflix catalog of content on the horizon and substantial value for consumers. Once the old guard have been disintermediated and a more open, consumer friendly market for content prevails every Christmas will be a little brighter (that's kind of a stretch?). In my opinion what's in play today with respect to old media firms is not so different from the agency model that kept eBook prices artificially high for many consumers.

So what about the Global Load Balancer Already?
Most Cloud Architect and Solution Architects of high availability systems are familiar with Load Balancers. AWS designed a mostly well-intended and useful service around this technology and it's often referred to as the (infamous) ELB (Elastic Load Balancer). Functionally a "classic" load balancer distributes service requests across hosts grouped into a pool of largely identical servers. Spreading requests across multiple servers is a key capability required for the horizontal scale-out favored by Cloud and to a lesser degree Enterprise Architecture.

A Global Load Balancer operates one or more levels above the Local Load Balancer. Similar to a classic DNS server, the Global Load Balancer returns an ip address. Often the IP address is the address of a Local Load Balancer but could be configured to return a public or private ip address. The IP address or VIP returned is determined by the specific solution requirements. Because Global Load Balancer technology stands on the shoulders of a fundamental and ubiquitous technology like DNS, the service can be very resilient if configured that way. If LLB (Local Load Balancer) high-availability solution is designed correctly the Load Balancer monitors the health and responsiveness of a pool of servers and directs requests to nodes of an application. A Global Load Balancer performs a similar function, except at a data center level. A Global Load Balancer can detect when a Local Load Balancer is no longer available, and when this happens can return the ip address of a load balancer or endpoint in another data center anywhere in the world. As it is based on DNS technology the Global Load Balancer is not coupled to a specific network. Moreover, the top-level domain is likely not hosted in any Cloud, and so provides a degree of separation. Further, Global Load Balancers can determine the nearest endpoint for a specific user request, and can return an endpoint closest to a user. Global Load Balancers can be configured to monitor the latency of response times across a pool of endpoints. In times of network failure, the endpoint that is normally "closest" or "lowest latency" frequently becomes a very high latency endpoint. So the ability to monitor latency and to adapt how it responds to requests based on latency, enables a very fine grained capability to direct users around system and network anomalies such as those that continue to plague US-EAST-1.

My observation is simply this: why don't Cloud or Web firms take a lesson from classic availability architecture and use a load balancer to enable endpoints to fail across data centers. For enterprise, why make Cloud an either/or question. And why gamble with the availability of important systems when it's not so difficult (especially if you've figured out the persistence layer) to balance systems across multiple Clouds. Using such an architecture to enable rapid switching of endpoints to other data centers could enable an enterprise to run an application both in the Cloud and in the data center and to balance traffic across them not in the sense of the much hyped "Cloud Bursting" which seems to focus mostly on "bursty capacity" but rather as a strategy for mitigating risk and reducing the correlated risk of running Load Balancers and applications within a single specific Cloud, even in multiple availability zones (as in the case of AWS). Hurricane Sandy in New York City would have been far more disruptive if not for systems built using Global Load Balancers for high availability. While there's no comparison to the complexity of failing over critical, albeit smaller-scale platforms to Netflix, several non-web facing internal applications for which I designed the architecture in 2011-2012 failed over to alternate data centers simply by  changing the endpoint returned by the Global Load Balancer.  In the case of Netflix, the option to migrate all the data was not an option, yet the instances remained healthy while those impacted by the ELB failure received no requests. An alternate strategy for directing traffic, in hindsight, could have made a difference.  It puzzles me to no end why given the extensive focus on Cloud failure modes, the AWS ELB remains a single point of failure for Netflix and many other applications running in AWS whether at modest or extreme scale.

I wonder if Netflix will select an additional Cloud in 2013 and in doing so create some real competition in the Cloud Service Provider space. After such a high profile failure (Christmas Eve, for Christ's Sake), I feel certain the decision has already been made. The impact of such a move would legitimize another Cloud. People who know these things tell me that 80% of Amazon Web Services capacity is in US-EAST-1. To me this suggest Amazon Web Services has fallen victim to it's own success. The nature of Clouds is such that as they grow bigger the network effect driven by the efficiency of locating data and compute capacity as close together as possible becomes overwhelming and the penalty for locating in another region, such as the West Coast, or another Cloud in another data center, becomes higher. While recently AWS has announced some capabilities to make it easier to migrate to the US-WEST-2 (Oregon region, which is priced about the same as US-EAST-1) such capabilities don't really seem to matter.

I spend a great deal of my time learning from web scale best practices such as those co-developed by firms like Netflix, Heroku, Pinterest, Google and redefine what people think they know about distributed computing..  Yet based on the theme of AWS re:invent, and my personal experience in Fortune 500 Cloud, 2012 may not only "not be the end of time and ancient calendars," but 2012 may mark the year when this thinking makes the leap and infects the DNA of Fortune 500 technology. The itchy little problem of Cloud as ready for big business remains the persistent failures, yet the risk of failures in hindsight can be minimized--and using technology commonly used by Enterprise that unlike Oracle RAC clusters and other High Availability technology works just fine in both Cloud and traditional data centers.

Listen closely to what Cloud and web scale practitioners have to teach. Architecture of Cloud applications deviates in ways that will make your database and application engineers pull-out their hair, scream, and storm out meetings (based on what I've seen, except for the hair pulling). For example the application server architecture and scale-out strategy for scaling applications in the Cloud is very different from how most of Fortune 500s do Enterprise Application Server clusters today. And after you fail in the Cloud trying to kick it old school, the enlightenment comes quickly. Yet at the same time, don't get too caught up in the hype and forget everything. The Global Load Balancer commonly used in large enterprise, when deployed effectively, could very well help you build applications which balance the new with the familiar.

Further Reading / Cultural Reception of Cloud

Summary of the December 24, 2012 Amazon ELB Service Event in the US-East Region

Some of the media reception of the events. I find the coverage to be grossly inaccurate, yet it's part of the cultural reception of the Cloud, so I've included some links:

‘The Cloud’ Challenges Amazon http://nyti.ms/ZBXT86

More Stories By Brian McCallion

Brian McCallion, founder of New York City-based consultancy Bronze Drum focuses on the unique challenges of Public Cloud adoption in the Fortune 500. Forged along the fault line of Corporate IT and line of business meet, Brian successfully delivers successful enterprise public cloud solutions that matter to the business. In 2011, while the Cloud was just a gleam in the eye of most Fortune 500 firms Brian designed and proved the often referenced hybrid cloud architecture that enabled McGraw-Hill Education to scale the web and application layer of its $160M revenue, 2M user higher education platform in Amazon Web Services. Brian recently designed and delivered the JD Power and Associates strategic customer facing Next Generation Content Platform, an Alfresco Content Management solution supported by a substantial data warehouse and data mart running in AWS and a batch job that processes over 500M records daily in RDS Oracle.”

Comments (0)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Cloud Expo Breaking News
Simply defined the SDDC promises that you’ll be able to treat “all” of your IT infrastructure as if it’s completely malleable. That there are no restrictions to how you can use and assign everything from border controls to VM size as long as you stay within the technical capabilities of the devices. The promise is great, but the reality is still a dream for the majority of enterprises. In his session at 14th Cloud Expo, Mark Thiele, EVP, Data Center Tech, at SUPERNAP, will cover where and how a business might benefit from SDDC and also why they should or shouldn’t attempt to adopt today.
MapDB is an Apache-licensed open source database specifically designed for Java developers. The library uses the standard Java Collections API, making it totally natural for Java developers to use and adopt, while scaling database size from GBs to TBs. MapDB is very fast and supports an agile approach to data, allowing developers to construct flexible schemas to exactly match application needs and tune performance, durability and caching for specific requirements.
APIs came about to help companies create and manage their digital ecosystem, enabling them not only to reach more customers through more devices, but also create a large supporting ecosystem of developers and partners. While Facebook, Twitter and Netflix were the early adopters of APIs, large enterprises have been quick to embrace the concept of APIs and have been leveraging APIs as a connective tissue that powers all interactions between their customers, partners and employees. As enterprises embrace APIs, some very specific Enterprise API Adoption patterns and best practices have started emerging. In his session at 14th Cloud Expo, Sachin Agarwal, VP of Product Marketing and Strategy at SOA Software, will talk about the most common enterprise API patterns and will discuss how enterprises can successfully launch an API program.
The social media expansion has shown just how people are eager to share their experiences with the rest of the world. Cloud technology is the perfect platform to satisfy this need given its great flexibility and readiness. At Cynny, we aim to revolutionize how people share and organize their digital life through a brand new cloud service, starting from infrastructure to the users’ interface. A revolution that began from inventing and designing our very own infrastructure: we have created the first server network powered solely by ARM CPU. The microservers have “organism-like” features, differentiating them from any of the current technologies. Benefits include low consumption of energy, making Cynny the ecologically friendly alternative for storage as well as cheaper infrastructure, lower running costs, etc.
Next-Gen Cloud. Whatever you call it, there’s a higher calling for cloud computing that requires providers to change their spots and move from a commodity mindset to a premium one. Businesses can no longer maintain the status quo that today’s service providers offer. Yes, the continuity, speed, mobility, data access and connectivity are staples of the cloud and always will be. But cloud providers that plan to not only exist tomorrow – but to lead – know that security must be the top priority for the cloud and are delivering it now. In his session at 14th Cloud Expo, Kurt Hagerman, Chief Information Security Officer at FireHost, will detail why and how you can have both infrastructure performance and enterprise-grade security – and what tomorrow's cloud provider will look like.
Today, developers and business units are leading the charge to cloud computing. The primary driver: faster access to computing resources by using the cloud's automated infrastructure provisioning. However, fast access to infrastructure exposes the next friction point: creating, delivering, and operating applications much faster. In his session at 14th Cloud Expo, Bernard Golden, VP of Strategy at ActiveState, will discuss why solving the next friction point is critical for true cloud computing success and how developers and business units can leverage service catalogs, frameworks, and DevOps to achieve the true goal of IT: delivering increased business value through applications.
Web conferencing in a public cloud has the same risks as any other cloud service. If you have ever had concerns over the types of data being shared in your employees’ web conferences, such as IP, financials or customer data, then it’s time to look at web conferencing in a private cloud. In her session at 14th Cloud Expo, Courtney Behrens, Senior Marketing Manager at Brother International, will discuss how issues that had previously been out of your control, like performance, advanced administration and compliance, can now be put back behind your firewall.
More and more enterprises today are doing business by opening up their data and applications through APIs. Though forward-thinking and strategic, exposing APIs also increases the surface area for potential attack by hackers. To benefit from APIs while staying secure, enterprises and security architects need to continue to develop a deep understanding about API security and how it differs from traditional web application security or mobile application security. In his session at 14th Cloud Expo, Sachin Agarwal, VP of Product Marketing and Strategy at SOA Software, will walk you through the various aspects of how an API could be potentially exploited. He will discuss the necessary best practices to secure your data and enterprise applications while continue continuing to support your business’s digital initiatives.
The revolution that happened in the server universe over the past 15 years has resulted in an eco-system that is more open, more democratically innovative and produced better results in technically challenging dimensions like scale. The underpinnings of the revolution were common hardware, standards based APIs (ex. POSIX) and a strict adherence to layering and isolation between applications, daemons and kernel drivers/modules which allowed multiple types of development happen in parallel without hindering others. Put simply, today's server model is built on a consistent x86 platform with few surprises in its core components. A kernel abstracts away the platform, so that applications and daemons are decoupled from the hardware. In contrast, networking equipment is still stuck in the mainframe era. Today, networking equipment is a single appliance, including hardware, OS, applications and user interface come as a monolithic entity from a single vendor. Switching between different vendor'...
Cloud backup and recovery services are critical to safeguarding an organization’s data and ensuring business continuity when technical failures and outages occur. With so many choices, how do you find the right provider for your specific needs? In his session at 14th Cloud Expo, Daniel Jacobson, Technology Manager at BUMI, will outline the key factors including backup configurations, proactive monitoring, data restoration, disaster recovery drills, security, compliance and data center resources. Aside from the technical considerations, the secret sauce in identifying the best vendor is the level of focus, expertise and specialization of their engineering team and support group, and how they monitor your day-to-day backups, provide recommendations, and guide you through restores when necessary.
Cloud scalability and performance should be at the heart of every successful Internet venture. The infrastructure needs to be resilient, flexible, and fast – it’s best not to get caught thinking about architecture until the middle of an emergency, when it's too late. In his interactive, no-holds-barred session at 14th Cloud Expo, Phil Jackson, Development Community Advocate for SoftLayer, will dive into how to design and build-out the right cloud infrastructure.
You use an agile process; your goal is to make your organization more agile. What about your data infrastructure? The truth is, today’s databases are anything but agile – they are effectively static repositories that are cumbersome to work with, difficult to change, and cannot keep pace with application demands. Performance suffers as a result, and it takes far longer than it should to deliver on new features and capabilities needed to make your organization competitive. As your application and business needs change, data repositories and structures get outmoded rapidly, resulting in increased work for application developers and slow performance for end users. Further, as data sizes grow into the Big Data realm, this problem is exacerbated and becomes even more difficult to address. A seemingly simple schema change can take hours (or more) to perform, and as requirements evolve the disconnect between existing data structures and actual needs diverge.
SYS-CON Events announced today that SherWeb, a long-time leading provider of cloud services and Microsoft's 2013 World Hosting Partner of the Year, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 14th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 10–12, 2014, at the Javits Center in New York City, New York. A worldwide hosted services leader ranking in the prestigious North American Deloitte Technology Fast 500TM, and Microsoft's 2013 World Hosting Partner of the Year, SherWeb provides competitive cloud solutions to businesses and partners around the world. Founded in 1998, SherWeb is a privately owned company headquartered in Quebec, Canada. Its service portfolio includes Microsoft Exchange, SharePoint, Lync, Dynamics CRM and more.
The world of cloud and application development is not just for the hardened developer these days. In their session at 14th Cloud Expo, Phil Jackson, Development Community Advocate for SoftLayer, and Harold Hannon, Sr. Software Architect at SoftLayer, will pull back the curtain of the architecture of a fun demo application purpose-built for the cloud. They will focus on demonstrating how they leveraged compute, storage, messaging, and other cloud elements hosted at SoftLayer to lower the effort and difficulty of putting together a useful application. This will be an active demonstration and review of simple command-line tools and resources, so don’t be afraid if you are not a seasoned developer.
SYS-CON Events announced today that BUMI, a premium managed service provider specializing in data backup and recovery, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 14th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 10–12, 2014, at the Javits Center in New York City, New York. Manhattan-based BUMI (Backup My Info!) is a premium managed service provider specializing in data backup and recovery. Founded in 2002, the company’s Here, There and Everywhere data backup and recovery solutions are utilized by more than 500 businesses. BUMI clients include professional service organizations such as banking, financial, insurance, accounting, hedge funds and law firms. The company is known for its relentless passion for customer service and support, and has won numerous awards, including Customer Service Provider of the Year and 10 Best Companies to Work For.